Three Pogendorf Challenges

Sorry for no updates yesterday. Still in rush and figuring which apartment to rent, so hope you’ll forgive. About today’s Poggendorf illusion – it is one of the most famous distortion illusions known. Although much has been written about it since its discovery in 1860, the underlying mechanism that gives rise to this effect is still not well understood. An adequate explanation of the Poggendorf illusion must take all the above factors into account, as well as several others. For example, the Poggendorf illusion is not confined to two-dimensional representations: It also occurs with three-dimensional objects. Secondly, perspective cues can have a drastic effect on diminishing the effect of this illusion. It’s interesting to know that the Poggendorf illusion is over 100 years old, there have been no end of theories to try to account for it. To show you what I mean, here are some examples inside this article. Try and guess which of the 4 parallel lines on the right is the logical extension of the red line on the left. Visual explanation, and more examples inside!






36 Replies to “Three Pogendorf Challenges”

  1. it’s a harder angle to determine the outcome of the problem. ( yes i said harder ) Knowing that i am programmed to handle this type of data on a daily horizontal or vertical bases. I will make an adjustment and tilt my head 45 degree’s haha Poggendorf your not tricking me. Orientation illusion cracked…

  2. Now was that a paragraph illusion? because you filled it with so many BIG words we might not notice your poor punctuation and spelling? It’s Basis, and Degrees.

  3. i agree, it was kinda boring.

    it was boring because its always easy to guess that somehow these are going to fool you and then you guess correctly.

  4. I think the first one works the best because you automatically assume the rest of the line to be red. That’s why I chose the yellow one… But I was still wrong… I think the colors definitely play a large role because the monkey one was the only one I got right. Super cool illusion; it’s awesome knowing it’s such a mystery.

  5. I've liked the Pogendorf illusion since i first saw it:) it's very entertaining, better when there's more than one person trying to do it though, humph!:P lol – although once you've done maybe 2, you get the gist of whats going on and can better work out which is the correct one, without using a ruler or your hand :P… i got 2 of these right, the one with the WHITE one starting i didn't get, i chose red… instead of yellow ;) although i did it quite fast :P
    Thanks for sharing. && Pick the cosiest apartment;)

  6. The first two were tricky for sure, but the last one absolutely through me for a loop… I thought it lined up higher than it actually did, where with the first two I believed it lined up lower.

  7. The beauty of this illusion does appear to dissapear when one tilts their head – it does become much easier to match the lines. In Encyclopaedia Britanica, I found this comment: “The Poggendorff illusion depends on the steepness of the intersecting lines. As obliqueness is decreased, the illusion becomes less compelling.”

    I suspect that by tilting the head, you are in effect adjusting the “steepness” of the lines and defeating the illusion.

    So if you want to trully appreciate Poggendorf’s illusion as it was intended, keep your head straight — and no artificial aids!

  8. Very cool. The fishing sign where I got this link from fooled me. Kinda knew what to look for after the first link but still got the last one wrong (didn’t tilt head). Picked green. Still fun to do. Good job finding all these illusions! And I agree about rudeness, rude people stay off here unless you have time to do this yourself.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *