Simmilar illusions were posted number of times here, on Mighty Optical Illusions. Still I never get tired of user submitted illusions, so here’s a new example of Hand inside the Monitor. Harvey Layton, creator of this image said: “Sorry bout the quality of photo. No hands left to take the pic.” Can you solve how this one was created?
I bet that this is a simple retouche of a man in front of the laptop and a calculator screenshot cut into that photo… I’ll take ’bout 10 min to do that… Really simple Photoshop work…
Oli: More likely (part of) the left hand (and the calculator) are displayed on the computer screen. No Photoshop necessary!
i think the left hand, the calculator and the laptop are a photoshopped picture displayed on a screen. the right hand pointing, is “real”. The picture is taken by the left hand.
i think this has been shown too many times lets see something new!
Yeah, these have been floating around for awhile now. Nice wow effect on first glance, but a little more looking reveals some missing details.
Specifically, this would look better (I think) with something actually displayed on the laptop screen, such as the dashboard mode that the hand has ‘scooped’ the calculator out of….
Maybe I’m missing something, but isn’t a flash supposed to distribute light on every object in it’s path?
This is very basic. It’s two pictures and an edited screenshot. The first picture is of the left hand and Macbook Pro (you could have turned it on). The lighting and shadows across the thumb and wrist give this away. The right hand is a separate photo and appears darker and rather out of place. Finally the screenshot of the calculator is layered in between the two pictures.
I don’t know why I even bothered to explain that, because you all are intelligent and already knew everything I just said.
My mistake, it appears that the computer is in fact on, but is dimmed all the way for some reason. It seems as if you can barely make out part of the dock. Doesn’t change how the image was created, but just correcting my comment.
@ Poit!
No need, all us intelligent lot already new.
Picture of hand holding nothing set as wallpaper.
Open calculator program and place correctly.
Real hand on the right.
Take picture without monitor edges.
i think the mans left hand is in the picture and the right hand is real so he takes the pic with his left hand
Just check the color tones of the left and the right arms and hands. The difference between their tones suggests they have been captured at different instances.
what in the world!
IT LOOKS LIKE A MONKEY!!!!
=^.^=
It is SO simple people!!! The man is holding a REAL calculator and the screen behind it is black!!! And that’s also why there can’t be a desktop behind because then it would look really fakey!!!
I think its just the guy holding a print out on his hand of the calculator =I
There are a two pictures in there: That is why the pigments in the hand are different colors and sizes.
1. PICTURE A
He took a picture of his left hand (and part of his left arm) as if he were holding something.
2. He put that on his laptop and set it as his background.
3. He pulled up calculator in front of the picture of his hand.
4. PICTURE B (what you are looking at)
He pointed at it with his right hand while taking a picture with his left hand.
In picture A there is only a left hand on black background.
In picture B there is Picture A on a desktop, a laptop, and a right hand.
No photoshop. No physical calculator. No extra person.
CHANGED MY MIND AGAIN-THIS 1 IS FOR REAL!
1st, he took a picture of his left hand with his right hand in front of his computer with a black screen as his desktop. He made sure to show the whole laptop.
2nd, he set that picture as his desktop.
3rd, he pulled up his dashboard and placed his calculator widget in front of the picture of his left hand.
4th, he pointed to the calculator widget with his right hand while taking the picture with is left hand.
5th He might have cropped it if the border of the physical laptop was showing so that you could not see the border of the physical laptop.
That is why the colors or the hand are different size and colors and the calculator does not line up with what you think is the laptop (because its a calculator on the laptop picture as the desktop).
The icons are dark on the bottom because it is on his dashboard. And, that is why calculator is orange-it is a widget.
~~Ceanne
good job.
ceanne is right, i think, though a phisical calculator is a possibility.
Ok, call me stupid, but I think he’s just holding a normal calcualator in front of his laptop
and has stuck it on with double-sided tape!
This illusion would have been more believable if his computer was actually switched on!
Thats just my opinion
ok i think either he took a picture of the calculator on dashboard (cntrl+shift-4) and printed it out, or he took a picture of his hands in front of the computer like that and a picture of just the computer and photoshopped them together so that only the calculator came out of the computer screen. its very simple, really.
Hey Guys, Just Saw This Webbie Today, And For this post, the Real reason is just the use of Distance, the guy just took the pic with his right hand real close to the camera and puts his left hand as far as possible, it’s will naturally creates this illusion.. try it with your own camera and u will see it for yourself..
Cheers!!
Jovan
Hey Guys,
It’s Actually very simple, the guy just puts his right hand real close to the camera while putting his left hand as far as possible.. and naturally, it will create this illusion.. try it out yourself with any camera and u will see it yourself..
Cheers!!!
Jovan
Okay, some of you have it right, I do not think it was photoshopped, this is what I think happened.
1. with the laptop off, take a picture of your left hand in front of a black screen (with the laptop edges in view).
2. set the picture to your background.
3. open the calculator program and position the window so it looks like the picture of your left hand is holding it.
4. point at the calculator with your right hand, and take the picture with your left hand(without the edges of the monitor visible).
simple! no photoshop, no physical calculator.
THIS IS NOT HARD
Obviusly its just a real photo infront of the laptop.
The reason why the screen is dark is because of the flash(try if u dont believe me.)
and it is a real calculater
SORRY ABOUT MY SPELLING AM NOT GOOD
I think this can be done with no photoshopping. Take a picture of your left hand in front of the computer, using your right hand. Make that picture the background on the computer. Open the calculator and arrange it over the background. Take a picture of the whole setup with your left hand holding the camera and your right hand pointing at the calculator buttons. Crop it so the edge of the computer monitor (in the second picture) is out of view. Viola! No photoshop!
I think that its no illusion at all. I belive he made cut-out calculator to fit in hand held against screen and took picture because if you look close you can see shadow from left hand on monitor
he just simply took a pic of a calculater and cut it out
then he just put it in his hand but dont know how he took the pic though
P.S the colour differents is your palms farer skin than your arm and mans arm is hairier
spelling good?
Man, i could do that in 15 minutes, the guy took a pic of his left hand in front of the notebook, a screenshot of the calculator (which he cut out with MSpaint or photoshop) and one of his other hand pointing at something. He opened photoshop and made the pic. Simple!
Cheers!
Look at your left hand: it is possible to bend fingers back that you see only a forearm, a thumb and a part of inside your palm.
Then you take a photo of whole left hand palm, set it as wallpaper, display a calc in the front, mask a part of it with particulary shaped left hand, add a right hand and take another photo (with mouth?). No photoshop needed. Little color differences are possible and are not a caouse of claim ;-)
The lighting of the right and left hand are completely different.
hola i from is chilean y me encanta esta pagina ctm
If you look closely at the left hand you will notice the thumb nail looks like its been hit with a hammer. Somewhere along the line a hammer must have been used to create this illusion.
Here’s my attempt to recreate the illusion… No photoshop done, except the part where I blotted out some logo’s visible in the picture that I’m not allowed to share…
http://img840.imageshack.us/img840/5665/handholdingcalculatorin.jpg
Hope the author will post my illusion…
I got an easier idea – another person took it.
I got it. Three layers. The first layer, desktop background of a hand on a screen of a laptop no edit needed. Second layer, The calculator program on the desktop background. Third layer, the real pointing hand. This might be a late reply. :D
Okay, the simpliest solution is Editing photoshop, as many said, right hand looks different. Another solution is..to put cam on a tripod, set delay for trigger, or last “weird” hold a cam (small enough) with your mouth :)))
Hes holding the camera with his mouth..
He probably set his camera on timer, some cameras have one.